Unable to escape the theater world, Rachael has been coerced into writing a play for her aunt, her cronies, and Ralph, the resident ghost. They all have their own ideas about what should be written and aren't above pestering Rachael unremittingly and driving her up a wall. So it's a relief when Rachael hears the news that the pie goddesses are back in town, back to baking their wonderful pies. She needs some sort of reward for putting up with her aunt, the eccentric posse, and a ghost. Unfortunately, the sisters brought back more than new ideas with them. They managed to pick up a boy toy, and he has his own ideas about how they should run their diner...ideas that are really upsetting the townspeople. When the boy toy disappears, whispers about the sisters' involvement begin, and when his body is found, the whispers grow into rampant rumor. The two sisters beg Rachael to use her psychic powers to find his killer. Not wanting to lose her pie privileges and thinking she won't be of any use anyway, she agrees to help. Unfortunately, the killer has more faith in her powers than she does, threatening to make her playwright debut her last act.